[hoppson]

So I have one single question:
How did Saskia fall under Philipas control if you took Roche's path?
The Rose of Remembrance was critical to the spell used, and on Roche's path you never give it to her.

[cmdr_silverbolt]

You give it to Triss at one point so she can prepare the spell to return Geralt's memories, and Cynthia still captures Triss when she arrives in Vergen seeking Phillipa.