The Witcher board : A logical error - The Witcher board

Jump to content

Community Discussions

ssssssssssssssss

Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

A logical error

Bleor 

    • Posts: 87
    • Joined: 10 September 11
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
246120
351

10.05.2012 @ 11:30 #1

It has probably been a thread about this before, but as I've never seen one I'm bringing it up. At the point when Triss and Geralt are having sex beneath the roses of rememberence some Scoia'Tael walks inn and notices that the bandits have been killed by a witchers blade. How can they notice this and not notice that Ciaran and his unit was attacked by a witchers blade, and assume that it was Loredo's soldiers who did it?
0


    • Posts: 170
    • Joined: 16 March 12
    • Location: Rhode Island
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip

10.05.2012 @ 11:32 #2

Maybe Letho used his daggers to kill them, like on Demavend's boat?

or

Maybe now they know what a Witcher blade cut looks like after being informed of how Ciaran and his unit died.
1

Bleor 

    • Posts: 87
    • Joined: 10 September 11
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
246120
351

10.05.2012 @ 11:36 #3

Hotnels said:

Maybe Letho used his daggers to kill them, like on Demavend's boat?

or

Maybe now they know what a Witcher blade cut looks like after being informed of how Ciaran and his unit died ›››

The daggers would make sense, but if they learned from Ciaran's unit's death they would have to know that a witcher killed them and they do not
0


    • Posts: 29
    • Joined: 29 April 12
  • Member
  • PipPip

10.05.2012 @ 11:39 #4

In the books a "Witcher's blade" is defined as a longsword forged out of meteorite - lightweight, thin and sharp as a razor yet nearly unbreakable. It is implied that Geralt always carries one. Victims look like they were sliced with a giant razor - it's how Geralt figures out the dead Salamandra thugs in TW1 swamps were killed by Berengar.

However, the big heavy longsword Letho uses during your first bossfight is an ordinary Temerian blade - not to mention that Letho, knowing he must maintain his charade, could have simply hacked the elves to pieces instead of using distinctive Witcher slashing techniques.
~inveniam viam aut faciam~
1

Aver 

    • Posts: 1734
    • Joined: 26 June 06
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
9102
2989

10.05.2012 @ 11:41 #5

Letho has different fighting style than other witchers. You can read it in his companion journal that you can find in ACT2.
If you see a grammar mistake in my post, then I don't mind if you send me a notice about it via PM. I always want to improve my English grammar.
0


    • Posts: 170
    • Joined: 16 March 12
    • Location: Rhode Island
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip

10.05.2012 @ 11:41 #6

Bleor said:

The daggers would make sense, but if they learned from Ciaran's unit's death they would have to know that a witcher killed them and they do not ›››


True I forgot that happens before meeting Iorveth. He probably used the daggers anyway as Letho only seems to use his sword for duels. Plus he wanted a surprise attack the daggers are quicker and stealthier and good for groups, as seen on Demavend's boat. Also he could have used daggers because he knew the Elves would recognize a Witcher's blade ha.
0

Bleor 

    • Posts: 87
    • Joined: 10 September 11
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
246120
351

10.05.2012 @ 11:41 #7

Emberstrife said:

In the books a "Witcher's blade" is defined as a longsword forged out of meteorite - lightweight, thin and sharp as a razor yet nearly unbreakable. It is implied that Geralt always carries one.

However the big, heavy longsword Letho uses during your first bossfight is an ordinary Temerian blade - not to mention that Letho, knowing he must maintain his charade, could have simply hacked the elves to pieces instead of using distinctive Witcher slashing techniques. ›››

As Ciaran survived, I doubt he hacked them to pieces. But that he carries a longsword sounds reasonable, but Geralt doesn't have a typical witchers steel sword either?
0

Bleor 

    • Posts: 87
    • Joined: 10 September 11
  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
246120
351

10.05.2012 @ 11:46 #8

Aver said:

Letho has very different fighting style than other witchers. You can read it in his companion journal that you can find in ACT2. ›››

But does that affect what kind of traces the sword leaves after a cut?
0


    • Posts: 29
    • Joined: 29 April 12
  • Member
  • PipPip

10.05.2012 @ 11:49 #9

Aver said:

Letho has different fighting style than other witchers. You can read it in his companion journal that you can find in ACT2. ›››



Well spotted! Here are his companion's notes from the wiki:



Although it can be interpreted in another way. The Viper school clearly teaches dual-wielding - which no other school does, - yet Letho fights with a single heavy blade. Perhaps that's what Serrit finds "funny yet effective" about his style?
~inveniam viam aut faciam~
0

Share this topic:


Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

1 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users